The bottom line
The advice (eat plants, move, connect, have purpose) is sound and independently evidence-based, but the Blue Zones branding rests on demographic data now credibly challenged for record-keeping fraud and age exaggeration. Follow the habits; distrust the mythology and the commercial ecosystem built on it.
Mechanism
Not a single intervention but a bundle of population-level habits observed in long-lived regions (Okinawa, Sardinia, Ikaria, Nicoya, Loma Linda): predominantly plant-based moderate diets, constant low-grade natural movement, strong social/family ties, sense of purpose, and stress-downshifting routines. The proposed benefit is the synergy of these factors sustained over a lifetime.
What the human evidence shows
Blue Zones are demographic observations, not experiments, and the individual components (plant-forward diet, activity, social connection, purpose) each have independent supporting evidence. However, the underlying claims of extreme longevity clustering have come under serious scrutiny: analyses (notably Saul Newman's work) attribute many supercentenarian clusters to poor birth-record keeping, pension fraud, and age misreporting rather than genuine lifestyle-driven longevity. The concept popularizes good habits but is not rigorous causal science.
Typical protocol studied
Plant-forward diet, daily natural movement, social connection, purpose ('ikigai'), moderate/no alcohol, stress reduction.
Safety
The healthy behaviors are risk-free. The risk is intellectual: treating a marketed brand as validated science.
Key studies
Supercentenarian and remarkable-age records show patterns of clerical error and pension fraud (Newman)(2019)
Blue-Zone-style extreme-age clusters correlate with missing birth records and fraud, not just lifestyle.
bioRxiv 704080 (2019)
Adventist Health Study-2 (Loma Linda vegetarians)(2013)
Vegetarian dietary patterns associated with lower all-cause mortality.
PMID: 23836264 (JAMA Intern Med 2013)