3 interventions in Supplement graded Contested or refuted.
Omega-3 Fatty Acids (EPA/DHA)
The definitive large RCT (VITAL) was essentially null for hard outcomes in the general population, and omega-3 did not even move telomere length. Benefit is real but confined to specific high-risk cardiovascular subgroups at high doses. As a broad longevity supplement, the evidence is underwhelming.
Resveratrol
The archetype of longevity hype collapsing under scrutiny: discredited primary mechanism, negative ITP lifespan results, disappointing human trials, and terrible bioavailability. If any single supplement should have exited the longevity conversation, it is this one. Marketing far outlived the science.
Vitamin D
A perfect example of correlation vs causation: low vitamin D tracks with bad health, but supplementing replete people did not cut mortality or cancer in the definitive RCT. The 2025 telomere finding is intriguing and worth following, but as of now the honest story is 'fix deficiency, do not expect miracles from extra.'